THREE EVs.
TWO OPINIONS.
ONE DRIVEWAY.
Two adults. Two boys (9 & 11). One rather substantial Groodle named Rusty. And exactly one car to do it all.
APPROVALPENDING
SO, WHO'S WINNING?
A close two-car race. And a wildcard with great seats.
The lead can flip when you value different things. Safety figures are externally tested; comfort, resale and future tech contain much more judgement. Tesla’s autonomy score credits optional paid FSD, which is excluded from the default ownership cost.
THE COST OF FALLING IN LOVE.
Five years, 25,000 km, garaged in Carnegie. These are estimates, not insurer quotes or crystal-ball resale forecasts.
Five-year net cost
$149/month × 60 months = $8,940. Optional subscription. Still not driverless.
🎛️ Stress-test the numbers +
Play with five-year resale value and annual comprehensive insurance. Every change recalculates the ownership cost. These start as modelling assumptions.
CAN IT HANDLE THE GANG?
Family practicality + comfort = 35% of the decision. This matters more than another tenth off the 0–100 time.
THE RUSTY TEST
Can a large Groodle stand, turn and lie comfortably in the boot with all four humans aboard? Boot litres aren't a reliable cross-brand comparison.
THE BACK-SEAT COMMITTEE
Legroom, vents, screen glare, heated seats and how the boys feel on a longer trip. Zeekr has a particularly strong comfort case.
THE 37°C TUESDAY
Cabin cooling, roof shade, parked climate features and whether the rear stays comfortable. BYD and Zeekr have powered roof shades.
THE INTERIOR DIPLOMACY ACCORD
BYD and Zeekr feel comparable to you. Lauren leans Tesla. Neither of you dislikes any option, so interior styling is not a deal-breaker.
PROMISES, PROMISES.
Two genuinely exciting technologies. Neither should get full credit for something it can't do with your hardware today.
Drive itself?
Model Y has the clearest demonstrated Australian supervised point-to-point driving. FSD costs extra and still requires a driver. BYD and Zeekr offer more conventional assisted driving on these variants.
Power the house?
BYD has a manufacturer-backed Australian V2G program involving the Sealion 7. But none of the three is verified as manufacturer-approved for your Sigenergy DC charger.
Your DC charger is already bidirectional-capable. The remaining blockers are car support, software approval, warranty and real-world coordination with your Sigenergy battery + gateway.
SAFE, SECURE, STILL WORKING.
When it's your only car, a long repair delay or a failed cloud service matters more than a fancy launch mode.
ANCAP: THE PUBLISHED NUMBERS
2025 protocols · 5-star ratingsPercentage scores by category, not accident probabilities. Results reflect the rated Australian variants.
Who gets your data?
All three are connected cars. Tesla has relatively clear owner privacy settings. BYD and Zeekr raise additional jurisdiction and overseas-transfer questions. We have not established that any vehicle is spyware.
Who gets you home?
Tesla has a mature Australian repair ecosystem; BYD has been expanding parts and service coverage; Zeekr's local network is smaller. BYD has a six-year vehicle warranty; the others five years.
NO BAD CHOICES.
JUST TRADE-OFFS.
THE HEAD SAYS
Model Y: the strongest technology-and-practicality package in this scorecard.
THE WALLET SAYS
Sealion 7: seriously competitive for substantially less money.
THE WILDCARD SAYS
Zeekr 7X: could change minds when you get behind the wheel.
SMALL PRINT. BIG DIFFERENCE.
Snapshot prepared 25 October 2026 for a household in Carnegie, Victoria. The scores are subjective comparative estimates. The acquisition prices use the prior Victorian promotional drive-away assumptions, not fresh binding dealer quotes. Insurance, tyre spend, depreciation and electricity are modelling estimates.
The published cashback deadline, subscriptions and manufacturer support can change. The 2026 purchase model includes $1,500 selected paint for BYD/Tesla; stock paint for Zeekr. Check on-road totals, stamp duty on paint and offer eligibility before purchase.
Nothing here is financial, safety or cybersecurity assurance. It's a structured way to choose what matters to your family.
MADE WITH TOO MUCH ANALYSIS, A LITTLE OPTIMISM & ONE VERY IMPORTANT DOG. 🐾